PRELIMINARY RESEARCH ON HEREDITARY FEATURES OF YINXU POPULATION
Zeng Wen1,4, Li Jiawei2, Yue Hongbin3, Zhou Hui2,4, Zhu Hong4
1 College of Humanities, Jilin University, 2College of Life Science, Jilin University,
3Institute of Archaeology CASS, 4Research Center for Chinese Frontier Archaeology, Jilin University
E-mail:
[email protected]
Introduction
Yinxu was the capital during the last phase of the Shang dynasty (ca. 1250-1050 B.C.).
It is located to the northwest of modern Anyang city in Henan province, China. It is one
of the oldest and largest archaeological sites in China, famous for the discovery of oldest
Chinese writings, the oracular bones. Historical and archaeological evidence suggests that
the Shang dynasty is first recorded dynasty of China (Li, 1985). The dynasty is also known
as the first monarchical slave state in Chinese history. Until today, no DNA research had
been done on the human remains of Yinxu.
Materials and Methods
0
0 - 500 m
500 - 1000m
Neolithic Period
1000 - 2000 m
Bronze Age
Iron Age
2000 - 3000 m
3000 - 5000 m
> 5000 m
Russia
Helongjiang
Mongonlia
Xinjiang
Jilin
YBLK
Inner Mongolia
Gansu
UXC DDZ
JHL
DDJ
XDZ
North
Korea
YXSG
ZKG
Liaoning
The archaeological and anthropological evidence show that people had lived in the Central Plain since
Neolithic period, aboriginal population grew fast and immigrants might have poured in as the
settlements developed rapidly. It is possiblethat the society of Yinxu was composed of individuals
coming from various regions during Shang Dynasty. Therefore we analysis the craniometric data of
the Yinxu and related ancient Chinese populations with Euclidean distance (Figure 2). The Yinxu and
DDZ groups clustered together firstly, then they clustered with ZKG groups. The distance between
Yinxu and JHL, JGZ and XDZ groups were significant. The result of this cluster analysis is similar to
Figure 3 Dendriform representaion of cluster analysis based on Dij values
the distance reflected in pairwise Fst value, suggesting
there is a close genetic affinity between the Yinxu and
0
5
10
15
20
25
2
DDZ-I
DDZ population, without major geographic barriers,
YX-B
10
HB
13
population movement and cultural exchanges potentially
ZKG
8
could occurbetween the West Liao-River valley and Central YXSG 1 2
9
UXC
Plain (Li H et al, 2011). Furthermore, considering the
JJL
11
TJZ
5
topographical features of location of Anyang, it is possible
YBLK-M 6
that the Yinxu ancient residents contained the culture and
JGZ
4
14
absorbed the genetic components of various contemporary DDJ
XDZ
7
NHL
1
populations who lived in north China.
HLHG
Hebei
Qinghai
TJZ
LJ
Shanxi
Ningxia
er
Fig 1 Haplogroup frequenciesSouth
of Yinxu and modern populaion
Figure 4 Frequency distribuion of mtDNA haplogroups in modern Chinese populaions
Shaanxi
YX
HB
Henan
Sichuan
ow
ll
e
Y
Shandong
Korea
Jiangsu
Austro-Asiatic
populations
Anhui
Hubei
Figure 1 Geographic locaion of ancient groups
Daic populations
Strict procedures and systematic controls were instituted to minimize the potential for
exogenous DNA contamination. The DNA extraction combined a complete demineralization
process with the QIAquick PCR Purification Kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany) according to
the manufacturer’s protocol. The fragments (393bp) of the mtDNA hypervariable region I
(HVR I) were amplified, sequenced and analyzed on the ABI PRISM 310 automatic
sequencer. According to the East Asian mtDNA classification tree (Kivisild et al., 2002),
the haplogroups were assigned using hypervariable region and coding region SNPs data.
Haplogroups M, F, D, C, G and B were examined using amplified product-length
polymorphisms (APLP) method. Haplogroups A, M10, N9a, and Z were identified by
sequencing. Sequence alignments were Abbr. Name of Site
Age (BP)
Archaeological Culture
5000
Hongshan 红山
analyzed using Clustal X1.83. An analysis NHL Njiuheliang 牛河梁
DDZ
4500-3500 Lower Xiajiadian 夏家店下层
Dadianzi 大甸子
of the molecular variance was performed ZKG Zhukaigou 朱开沟
4200-3500 Zhukaigou 朱开沟
LJ
4000-3800 Qijia 齐家
Lajia 喇家
on the 393 bp HVS-I sequences (np
YXSG Yuxianshanguan 蔚县三关 3000
Lower Xiajiadian 夏家店下层
spanning 16 017–16 409), using
HB
3000-2800 Hengbei 横北
Areliquin 3.15. The information of ancient JGZ Jinggouzi 井沟子
2500-2000 Jinggouzi 井沟子
2500
Chinese populations which were compared XDZ Xindianzi 新店子
TJZ
1500
Taojiazhai 陶家寨
with is presented in Table 1.
DDJ
1500
Dongdajing 东大井
Table 1 Informaion of ancient Chinese populaions
Results and Discussion
Out of 37 specimens examined, the fragments of HVR 1 of 30 samples were successfully sequenced.
They belonged to 30 haplotypes. Using coding region and HVR II SNPs data, combined with HVR I
sequences, all haplotypes were attributed to these (sub) haplogroups: A, B, C, D, F, G, M10, N9a,
and Z, which all belong to the East Eurasian pool of mtDNA lineages. The dominant haplogroup in
the Yinxu population was D(43.33%) shared by 13 individuals who were associated with 13 different
haplotypes. The northern East Asian-dominating haplogroups (A, C, D, G and Z) accounted for 80%
of Liujiazhuang population.
Figure 2 AMOVA between Yinxu and ancient Chinese populaions
0.08
0.45
0.07
0.40
A
C
D
Northern East
G
Asian-dominaing
M*
haplogroups
M8
M9
Z
N9a
Y
B
F
Southern East
M7 Asian-dominaing
N* haplogroups
R
other
Hmong-Mien
populations
Tibeto-Burman
populations
Altaic Populations
Southern Han
Chinese
Northern Han
Chinese
Yinxu poptualtion
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
0.06
0.35
0.05
0.30
0.04
0.25
0.03
0.20
0.02
0.15
0.01
0.10
0.00
0.05
-0.01
0.00
Fst
P
LJ
0.04689
0.00901
HB
0.01446
0.06306
ZKG
0.00654
0.22523
DDZ
-0.00016
0.39640
Fst
YXSG
0.04103
0.12613
P
JGZ
0.05898
0.00000
XDZ
0.04725
0.01802
TJZ
0.02596
0.03604
SD
0.04471
0.00000
80%
90%
100%
The Yinxu population bore a high genetic resemblance in maternal lineages to the northern
Han Chinese and other minority who lives in North China. The result of AMOVA between
Yinxu and modern Chinese populations (Table 2) shows that Yinxu population is not
significantly different (Fst value: 0.0073, P> 0.05) from northern Han Chinese, but
significantly different (Fst value> 0.03, P< 0.05) from southern populations. Compared with
Frequency distribution of mtDNA haplogroups in modern Chinese populations, the Yinxu
populations bore a high similarity to some northern Han and Tibeto-Burman populations.
On the basis of principal component analysis of mtDNA haplogroup frequencies (Figure 5),
the Yinxu population pooled into the cluster
Figure 5 PCA of mtDNA haplogroups frequencies of Yinxu
populaion and modern Chinese populaions
formed of the northern Han, Tibeto-Burman
1.0
and Altaic populations.
Table 2 AMOVA between Yinxu and modern Chinese populaions
F st
Grouping
Yinxu/Northern Han
0.00730 0.07207±0.0264
Yinxu/Southern Han
0.03188 0.00000±0.0000
Yinxu/Tibeto-Burman
0.01445 0.01802±0.0121
Yinxu/Hmong-Mien
0.5
P
0.05628 0.00000±0.0000
Yinxu/Daic
0.04184 0.00000±0.0000
Yinxu/Austro-Asiaic
0.05060 0.00000±0.0000
Yinxu/Alaic
0.00904 0.09910±0.0000
0.0
Yinxu ancient people
-0.5
-1.0
Northern Han Chinese
Southern Han Chinese
Altaic populations
Tibeto-Burman populations
Austro-Asiatic populations
Daic populations
Hmong-Mien populations
-0.5
NHL
0.07274
0.00000
3
v
Ri
PC 2
The 37 individuals sampled
in this study were recovered
from Liujiazhuang cemetery
(Figure 1). Most burials at
this cemetery are moderate
in tomb size and number of
grave goods, some of the
burials are relative poor. The
characteristics of grave
goods showed their
affiliation with Yinxu and the
tomb owners were probably
citizens of the city. This
assemblage constituted a
representative sample to
study the genetic structure
of Yinxu commoners.
800 km
Because few genetic analysis results have been published on ancient Chinese populations,
frequency distribution of mtDNA haplogroups can not be analyzed. AMOVA was used instead to
evaluate maternal genetic differentiation between Yinxu and other ancient Chinese (Figure 2). The
Fst value between Yinxu and DDZ populations was the lowest (-0.00016), The Fst value between
Yinxu and ZKG populations was second to the lowest. The Yinxu and HB populations presented a
lower and nonsignificant pairwise Fst value. However, the highly significant value was observed
between Yinxu and other historical period populations.
0.0
0.5
1.0
PC 1
Conclusion
Yinxu population had genetic communication with various contemporary populations and
significantly contributed to the formation of the matrilineal genetic heritage of the modern
northern Han Chinese population. However, we need research more thoroughly to draw a
further conclusion. The Y-chromosome DNA research is still ongoing, and will provide more
genetic information of Yinxu residents soon.
References
Acknowledgment
Kivisild, T., et al. (2002). Molecular Biology and Evolution 19, 1737–1751.
Li, H., et al. (2011). Journal of Human Genetics 56, 815–822.
Wen, B., et al. (2004). Nature 431, 302–305.
Zhao, et al. (2011). American Journal of Physical Anthropology 144, 258–268.
This study was supported by the graduate school of Jilin
University, National Philosophy and Social Science Foundation
(Grant number: 11&zd182)