12 Best Comforters for Your Coziest Sleep in 2024
All products are independently selected by our editors. If you buy something, we may earn an affiliate commission.
When it comes to buying home items, the most important purchases are the ones you’ll use every day. Chances are, you already know what separates a good comforter from a great one. The best comforters are ones that pull you back into bed even after you’ve hit the snooze button seven times.
We looked at studies and consulted Daniel Barone, MD, a New York City–based sleep medicine neurologist at Weill Cornell Medicine, to help us break down what you should look for in this essential sleep product; below, you’ll find our top picks at every price point.
In general, there are two main types of stuffing that can go inside your comforter: down and down alternative.
Down: Down fill is made with actual fluffy goose down (and often blended with duck and goose feathers). These comforters are extraordinarily fluffy, cozy, and warm—all while staying relatively lightweight. When shopping for a down comforter, we recommend looking for one that’s made with Responsible Down Standard (RDS) down, which means the goose farms are held to more humane expectations than non-RDS farms. Down comforters can be especially nice if you live in a colder climate or get chilly at night. Just be sure to read the care instructions for it, as some require delicate detergent or dry cleaning. And if you’re worried about allergies, know this: According to one study, feather allergies are actually fairly rare. If down comforters have made you sneeze in the past, it’s more likely due to mite allergens found in feathers—meaning you should be even more diligent about cleaning it.
Down Alternative: Down alternative fill is typically made with microfiber polyester, lyocell, silk, or wool. Silk and polyester fill are usually on the warmer end of the spectrum, whereas lyocell (which is made with plants like eucalyptus and wood pulp) is on the cooler end. These comforters are often less expensive than down options, starting at just $25, but they also aren’t as fluffy. Another bonus: Assuming you have a large enough washing machine, you can throw these right in to clean them.
Once you decide on a filling, think about how warm you like to be. “I prefer that my patients sleep on the cooler side, because data has shown that lower core body temperature promotes deep sleep,” Dr. Barone tells SELF.
So if you’ve got your heart set on a big, fluffy down comforter, you should turn down your thermostat or opt for cooling bed sheets to achieve that lower core body temp. Alternatively, you can also pick a lighter, down alternative comforter or one with a lower gram-per-square-meter (GSM) count in order to sleep cool. The GSM count refers to the weight of a comforter, and the higher the count, the heavier (and warmer!) it will be. Most of the comforters on this list have a GSM between 220 and 700—and according to enthusiastic reviews we read, that higher end will keep you warm in, say, Northeastern winters. A lower GSM is ideal for sweaty sleepers or anyone who lives in a warmer climate.
In addition to the weight and warmth of the comforter, we suggest looking for one that is described as having baffle-box-construction or diamond stitching, which means there are sections within the comforter to keep the fill from clumping or redistributing over time.
Best Down: Brooklinen Down Comforter
.png)
BrooklinenBrooklinen Down Comforter (Full/Queen Size)
Brooklinen’s down comforter is one of the brand’s bestsellers and has more than 2,000 five-star reviews. It’s made with duck and geese down clusters and feathers, and it has baffle-box construction, so each square is filled with down for even distribution. Plus, depending on whether you’re a hot or cold sleeper, you can opt for a lightweight, all-season, or ultrawarm fill power.
Sizes available: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king
Care instructions: Spot clean, dry clean
Colors: WhiteBest for Cold Climates: Utopia Bedding Comforter
.png)
AmazonUtopia Bedding Comforter Duvet Insert (Queen Size)
This comforter is filled with polyester fiberfill that many reviewers compare to a cloud, and it has box stitching that’ll keep the fluff in place. We recommend it for cold sleepers or folks who live in chilly climates, as reviewers note that it’s much warmer than they expected. One wrote: “I live in Wisconsin, and the temperatures this week have been ranging from -10 overnight to single digits during the day. I had been using two blankets prior to getting this one, but so far with this comforter alone I have stayed warm.”
Sizes available: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king
Care instructions: Machine wash in the gentle cycle with cold water, line dry or tumble dry on low heat only
Colors: White, beige, black, black/gray, burgundy, gray, light gray, navy, pink, plum, sage green, gray/white
Best Quilt Style: Coyuchi Diamond-Stitched Organic Cotton Comforter
.png)
CoyuchiCoyuchi Diamond-Stitched Organic Cotton Comforter (Full/Queen Size)
This lightweight comforter-quilt hybrid from Coyuchi has a pretty diamond stitch and a relaxed feel. It’s filled with organic cotton batting and, despite its being thinner than other options on this list, reviewers mention how comfortable it kept them all year round.
Sizes available: Twin, full/queen, king
Care instructions: Cold wash, gentle cycle with like colors, tumble dry low, and remove promptly
Colors: White, undyed, blue, light brownBest Down Alternative: Linenspa All-Season Down Alternative Comforter
.png)
AmazonLinenspa All-Season Down Alternative Comforter (Queen Size)
Here’s an Amazon bestseller from Linenspa made with a moderate to lightweight 300-GSM microfiber polyester fill. It’s fluffy, yes, but reviews note that it’s not overly warm. And, like many of the plainer options on this list, this can also fit in a duvet cover that matches your personal style. “I live in Miami, so I’ve been looking for bedding that won’t capture too much heat—or any at all. I’ve tried a bunch in the past, but THIS IS IT,” wrote one of more than 90,000 five-star reviewers.
Sizes available: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, oversized queen, king, oversized king, California king
Care instructions: Wash on gentle cycle and air dry
Colors: White, black/gray, light gray/white, navy/gray, beige/brown, light gray/gray
Best for Hot Climates: Buffy Breeze Lightweight Comforter
.png)
AmazonBuffy Breeze Lightweight Comforter (Full/Queen Size)
This cooling comforter from Buffy is an internet favorite for a reason. It’s temperature-regulating and moisture-wicking thanks to the Tencel lyocell (a.k.a. eucalyptus and other wood pulp spun into a fiber) fill. “I’m such a hot sleeper and this comforter is perfect for me! It’s also so soft and looks great when I make my bed,” wrote one reviewer.
Sizes available: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king
Care instructions: Dry clean only
Colors: WhiteBest Splurge: L.L.Bean Permabaffle Box Goose Down Comforter
.png)
L.L.BeanL.L.Bean Permabaffle Box Goose Down Comforter (Queen Size)
This 600-GSM goose down comforter is constructed with baffle box stitching to ensure that the fill stays put even after washing. The cotton cover is soft but slightly crisp, making it feel like you’re on a staycation at your favorite hotel. “The comforter lofts well and gives a very satisfying pillowy look to any cover,” wrote one reviewer. Though this is one of the more expensive options on our list—coming in at $569 for a queen size—with proper care, the comforter should last for years.
Sizes available: Twin, full, queen, king
Care instructions: Wash and dry in large commercial machine
Colors: Cream
Best Weighted: Baloo Weighted Comforter
.png)
BalooBaloo Weighted Comforter (Full/Queen Size)
Dr. Barone likes weighted blankets that can serve as comforters, as they provide a soothing and swaddling effect without feeling so warm. Baloo’s comes in 15-, 20-, and 25-pound weights and has an all-season fill. It has box stitching to keep its glass microbeads in place for even distribution across the comforter.
Sizes available: Full/queen, king
Care instructions: Wash on cold, gentle cycle and dry on low or no heat
Colors: White, silverBest Linen: Pottery Barn Belgian Flax Linen Comforter
Pottery BarnPottery Barn Belgian Flax Linen Comforter (Full/Queen Size)
Calling all linen fans: This comforter is woven with flax linen fibers that are a little soft and a little scratchy (in the best way). It’s available in tons of colors and offers a lived-in look that, thanks to the tufted stitching, still feels put together.
Sizes available: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, King/California king
Care instructions: Machine wash in cold water separately on gentle cycle, line or tumble dry on a low temperature
Colors: Heathered gray, dark heathered gray, dark gray, gray-black, black, light gray, gray-beige, light beige, ivory, white, light blue, light green-blue, heathered blue, gray-blue, denim blue, navy, dark green, green-gray, sage green, heathered beige, light brown, gold, yellow, cream, light pink, heathered pink-gray, light red, brown, cool brown, purple, berry, red, dark brown
Best Plush: Layla Down Alternative Comforter
.png)
LaylaLayla Down Alternative Comforter (Full/Queen Size)
Here’s a down alternative comforter that’s notably voluminous while still being filled with a moderately cool 300-GSM cotton. The hexagonal stitch pattern adds a touch of visual interest, making it suitable to throw on your bed sans cover.
Sizes available: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king
Care instructions: Machine wash cold, tumble dry low using large capacity machine
Colors: White, grayBest Duvet Insert: Parachute Down Alternative Duvet Insert
.png)
ParachuteParachute Down Alternative Duvet Insert (Full/Queen Size)
We love Parachute’s sheets and loungewear, so it’s no surprise that the brand also makes a great comforter. Choose from lightweight or all-season microfiber fill, and get ready to snap pics of your fluffy, Instagram-worthy messy bed.
Sizes available: Twin/twin XL, full/queen, king/California king
Care instructions: Dry clean or machine wash cold (delicate cycle recommended) using mild liquid laundry detergent, tumble dry low
Colors: White
Best Wool: Nest Bedding Washable Wool Comforter
.png)
Nest BeddingNest Bedding Washable Wool Comforter (Queen Size)
Here’s a lightweight option made with wool. Reviewers note that if you’re used to down or down alternative comforters, a wool one might not provide that swaddled feeling and may feel stiff at first, but it’s worth the adjustment period. “After sleeping under down comforters for years, this wool comforter is a breath of fresh air…literally. There are no shockingly cold areas, I don’t overheat, and the wool breathes beautifully,” wrote one reviewer.
Sizes available: Twin, queen, king
Care instructions: Machine wash on cold, separately, with a gentle cycle, use mild detergent
Colors: Off-whiteBest Versatility: Cozy Earth Comforter
Cozy EarthCozy Earth Comforter (Queen/Full Size)
Reviewers will tell you that Cozy Earth’s comforter is a worthwhile splurge. You can have it filled with mulberry silk or bamboo viscose, and you can choose standard or extra filling. “I sleep in a 63-degree room in the winter in New England, and this silk comforter is plenty warm, yet still feels like a cloud. It seems so very light when you first unpack, but it will surprise you,” wrote one reviewer.
Sizes available: Twin, full/queen, king
Care instructions: Spot clean or dry clean
Colors: White
SELF does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Any information published on this website or by this brand is not intended as a substitute for medical advice, and you should not take any action before consulting with a healthcare professional.
