Skip to content

opengiveback/OpenGiveBack

Folders and files

NameName
Last commit message
Last commit date

Latest commit

 

History

48 Commits
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Repository files navigation

OpenGiveBack.org

OpenGiveBack.org provides the explicit definitition to the moral obligation of paying back authors whose free, open-sourced designs you are selling (hardware or software) and earning profit for yourself. Enable people to circumvent procrastination of producing and selling someone else's open-sourced idea/code/designs when you know people need/want it. Every repository should have an opengiveback file and define the percentage they (verbally) require when someone produces and sells their open-source design, if they find the proposed default "fair" 15% of all sales profits not enough or too much.

You can access the files with logos in PNG, KiCad and DXF formats (for PCB application) on the OpenGivaBack github repository, so you can tell the world the OpenSource based software/hardware product you are selling is giving part of the profit back to the designers of the OpenSource sourcecode that enabled/invented it's existance.

Screenshot

OpenGiveBack agreement 0.6

OpenGiveBack, is a promise from the seller, that he is going to give back the stated part (15% unless stated otherwise) of his PROFITS, to the authors of the open-sourced solution he is producing and selling per their blueprint, or if he is the author, to the authors of libraries used in producing the software/hardware.

An author may also put the OpenGiveBack.org logo on his own product published as open-source, only to inform people that he expects those who profit from the software or hardware, to give back a certain amount of their profits from selling the product they produced, as per the author's designs.

OpenGiveBack categories of users

Opengiveback can be innitialized by 1.original developers and sellers of device or software, proclaiming opengiveback to authors of used open-sourced libraries, 2.producers/sellers of existing openhardware open source solution proclaiming open give back to authors of the entire project, or 3.open source publisher proclaiming producers/sellers of his solution should give back according to desired opengiveback rate.

OpenGiveBack Repayment Tiers

* opengiveback, produce open source hardware, give back 15% profit to 30% payed price, fair to unicorn to equal partners*

In an OpenGiveBack, you can be either an author/publisher of opensource software and/or hardware, or you can be a producer/seller, profiting from the open sourced work.

The actual amount returned to the author/publisher is always determined by the producer/seller, however the author/publisher can add an OpenGiveBack text file to his public open-source repository, in which he/she states what he considers to be a moral amount of OpenGiveBack for the design/product source files, AND to whom the total amount is to be payed (if the work is derived from previous work, or is made by multiple authors). All of these are defined in this OpenGiveBack.org definition text.

OpenGiveBack.org only provides a recomendation to donate back to authors of open-source, with no legal obligations and bindings, only moral ones.

The percentage of the profit to be returned can be chosen from the following OpenGiveBack Repayment Tiers, named scale, where the names represent the tier's desirability

  • 5% JUST TEASING/I just reverse engineered your stuff, bro
  • 10% GIVING BACK A BIT
  • 15% FAIR (implied default when no tier mentioned)
  • 20% ENOUGH
  • 25% RESPECT
  • 30% UNICORN
  • 50% EQUAL PARTNERS

There is also the option (for the author/publisher ONLY) to require he is not given anything. However, producers/sellers CAN NOT USE THE 0% TIER, AS THAT DEFEATS THE PURPOSE AND MEANING OF OpenGiveBack.org, i.e. you can't/shouldn't put the OpenGiveBack.org logo on the open-source based product if you don't donate at least 5% of total profits back to the author/publisher , and the repayment tier chosen should be stated below the logo and OpenGiveBack.org text.

The special, "author/publisher"-only" repayment tier is

  • 0% (in author's OpenGiveBack repository file only) NO NEED/Please DO NOT transfer any funds to me

Both hardware and software open-source designs (in physical products) together add-up to the percentage of profit defined by an OpenGiveBack Repayment Tier. It is up to the producer/seller to define the exact division of this total OpenGiveBack percentage of profits to software and hardware design author(s)/publisher(s), if they are different authors, based on the added value and indispensability as perceived by the producer/seller.

What exactly is the OpenGiveBack?

OpenGiveBack defines ways to profit from producing OpenSource Hardware/Software while retaining morality, by establishing an amount of profits per sold hardware unit to be transferred as donations to the original author/designer/publisher who published his solution to opensource, by the producer/seller.

Where there is only 1 designer, this is sufficient definition, however when the work is based on previously published opensource design by another author, this convention either leaves it to the author to assess how much value for the application he has added/how much the previous work is worth, and do his own OpenGiveBack if he so feels the need to.

Authors/publishers can also set an OpenGiveBack index, a percentage defining how much of the OpenGiveBack cash should be given to him, and how much to authors he based his work on. If defined, there should be an OpenGiveBack.txt file in the project directory. Every OpenGiveBack payment must include a note on it's type.

  • OpenGiveBackOnlyForYou is a payment not having the moral obligation of propagating to earlier authors, and the default form of OpenGiveBack used when otherwise not defined (to prevent too much requirement of self doubt and overthinking on the recipientduring normal application of this process, the intent is to reward the author not punish him). To avoid the definition including requirements of too much microtransactions, the relevant granularity for further propagation is set to 10 USD, meaning you as a recipient of OpenGiveBack funds should only send to other authors when their parts accumulate over 10$.
  • OpenGiveBackPleasePropagate/PleaseRecurse informs the author to redistribute the funds to the other/previous authors the work of whose the opensource design is based upon.

By proclaiming the desired profit sharing concept in the project directory, much like already done with the opensource license, you direct what happens with your work and avoid confusion should other be created.

The tier's name can be part of a custom sentence in the OpenGiveBack repository file/below the OpenGiveBack logo on the PCB/software About screen, just keep the tier name in all capital letters so that it is clear and obvious.

Here are examples of how you would state the desired OpenGiveBack repayment tier (default sentences, if customized please retain the tier name, and in all capital letters):

  • NO NEED for giving back money
  • JUST A LITTLE BIT of work
  • a FAIR amount of work
  • ENOUGH work
  • created a UNICORN for you

If you do not state the tier name, the default fair tier is always implied.

An entire category, much like opensource licenses only mostly in the moral dimension, is created by this. This is chosen so that application of OpenGiveBack can not lead to various, location/legislation dependent obligations arising for those who apply OpenGiveBack. It is entirely voluntary and non-compulsory. It is the same reason why So as to be compatible with opensource licenses, the obligation required by OpenGiveBack is purely a moral one. All people really have, is their word.

Verification process using email shall be established, but promoting tracking and lack of privacy is not what opengiveback.org is about, so this verification procedure shall remain completely optional, and mostly on seller's demand.

All consequences of not following any of these rules are moral only. Unless an opensource project has explicitly stated it belongs to the "NO NEED for money" category, it is hereby implied that every opensource project you make profit from producing, is eligble for OpenGiveBack.

OpenGiveBack is an attempt at a written social convention, a definition of Please donate to OpenGiveBack.org, allow us to keep being online and keep refining the idea of fair and moral openhardware production profit sharing.

Why not give the people who already invested work in the things that interest us, somewhat of a passive income source? OpenGiveBack is an open-ended set of guidelines to inspire and ease giving back to opensource solution designers, when their work is sold for profit by a third party. Why? Because if someone made something useful, and you're making profit off of their work, it's only fair to give some of it back to them. Primarily, for now, OpenGiveBack is inspired by OpenSource Hardware projects, and aims to inspire giving back and make it easy by resolving some of the unknowns and ambiguosities, by wraping it all up in a brand new social convention - OpenGiveBack. Also, individual producers and sellers of opensource hardware with the OpenGiveBack logo could incentivize conscientiouss people to pay a little more attention to this, support original designers a bit more, and make the world a somewhat better place.

Privacy is also very important, OpenGiveBack.org has a givebacktally option, however only when both giver and designer agree is it made public. A way for the author to automatically avoid this, is to have the keyword "private" in his OpenGiveBack config file in the repository in question

Like maestro singers who were doused with flowers, so shall the most popular authors on opengiveback.org receive the title of opengiveback's maestro, thus earning free promotion for his opensource work, and through the morality of those who produce it and suggestions from opengiveback.org, Because if someone gave you seeds to plant and grow beautiful flowers, it's only fair to give some back to the someone in question.

"I prefer to produce and supply hardware for my designs myself" option, addition to the logo meaning you prefer people get the open source hardware produced by you "I prefer to produce and supply hardware for my designs myself" "Designer also makes and supplies this opensource hardware, but this is DESIGNER ALSO SUPPLIES PRODUCED HARDWARE (THIS NOT PRODUCED AND SOLD BY DESIGNER)

The text "If you produce this open-source hardware for profit, please give back a fair amount" under OpenGiveBack.org text and logo, can be put in a smaller font by either author/designer or the producer/seller, and the fair keyword can be changed if author has defined another desired OpenGiveBack Repayment Tier.

When an author/designer adds the OpenGiveBack.org logo to his design and publishes it, he should also include words "Please update with producer's/seller's intentions and chosen OpenGiveBack tier" only in the published version of open-source files (not in the author-produced physical PCB itself), so that it is obvious when the logo is left untouched. Presence of this sentence on the designs means that probably, a producer/seller of such a design is not aware or doesn't care for OpenGiveBack.

About opensource software, to simplify it shall be established hardware and software are equally valuable, unless noted otherwise. If only a part of opensource software is used, but it is the basis and foundation to any additions, it can still be said software has value of half of device, and base necessary opensource sofware used all has at least half the value of all opensource software, unless otherwise decided.

Three ways of marking product as OpenGiveBack-er

Way 1(full disclosure):

Add (each in new line) to hardware PCB silkscreen OR software about message/splash screen/webisite.

a) logo graphics and

b) OpenGiveBack.org title below,

c) repayment tier, write applied(producer/seller) or desired(author/designer) (Gives back ENOUGH (20%) of profits to OpenSource project authors"

d) credit authors of used OpenSource projects, optional full repository addresses and percentages of OpenGiveBack.org donations for the project.

Optional OpenGiveBac explanation sentence.

Way 2(limited display):

Only a), b) and c) (at least tier name)

Optional OpenGiveBack explanation sentence.

Way 3(minimal):

Only b) and, if not implied or purposedfully not quoted, c) tier name (for ,minimum space requirements)

You can register your OpenGiveBack-er product on opengiveback.org, it shall be listed on the site after manual data verification.

Example of OpenGiveBack application

For example, if you have made entire hardware design, and are using someone else's opensource software in it's original form, a "fair" tier of OpenGiveBack would be 50% of the 15% )7.5% of profits) for "fair" tier, and it should be noted in the standard OpenGiveBack note with only software mentioned on the PCB. If however you have added features into the opensource with significant added value to the project, it would be fair to reduce the portion given to original opensource sw author down to at least 50%, so that he gets 3.75% of profits or more (if several opensource solutions are integrated by yourself, 50% of the software part, is shared among these solutions, and parts are equal or arbitered by you by significance to the project and added value to the project of each of the softwares, otherwise if you are using an already integrated solution, it is by default the integrrator's (moral) responsability to further divide what you send him, unless he explicitly stated in his OpenGiveBack file in his repository, that he wants the payee to distribute among people who's software he integrated. Any integrator is to get no less than 20% of the total sum.

The easiest job in determining the moral OpenGiveBack amount, is when assembling open source projects made from hardware and software made by the same person/team, in that case, there is only one recipient for the 15% profit share of the "fair" opengiveback tier. Defining new customs, to rtain honor and morality in the remote social landscape of contacts you never meet yet are using their work, published into opensource or with express permission but with no strings attached. For instance, if there are several suppliers of an assembled open hardware design, it could be more morally correct to choose the one with added OpenGiveBack.org logo, that takes care of the author too.

Legal Disclaimer

No warranties or legal obligations of any kind, express or implied, are imposed by this document. This document is only a proposition to, calling upon their morals, ease retention of morality by producers of open hardware or sellers of open software, with a concrete definition of how much of the profits and to whom to donate. This definition does not claim to be the only righteous way, it is just a definition reflecting it's author's (Milos Stojanovic) thoughts, values and experience.

This text has to bee shared in it's entirety and unchanged. Only OpenGiveBack.org author (Milos Stojanovic) can revise this text.

Use this as is on your own responsibility, no damages or injuries caused by or said to be caused by this document can be charged to the author of OpenGiveBack.org (Milos Stojanovic). In case any judicial claims should rise, they are to be settled by the court in Kursk, Russian Federation.

If you do not agree with this disclaimer, please do not use OpenGiveBack agreement. Otherwise, please do.

Contributing to OpenGiveBack.org

If you have any questions, or have percieved some inconsistencies with this agreement and the actions it proposes, or you have some suggestions, please open A new issue on the OpenGiveBack GitHub Repository

How should the logo look like on a PCB?

Here is an example of using OpenGiveBack.org logos on a PCB from the ISALTA project, the first project supporting OpenGiveBack.org.

Screenshot

The vector graphics and KiCad example are included in the OpenGiveBack github repository.

About

No description, website, or topics provided.

Resources

Stars

Watchers

Forks

Releases

No releases published

Packages

No packages published