Mosquitto last update does NOT start any more if Websockets port is defined

[beardsick]

For new Package Requests, see the guidelines

Setup

Package Name: Mosquitto
Package Version: 1.6.12-10

NAS Model: DS1019+
NAS Architecture: DSM 6.2.3-25426 Update 2
DSM version: DSM 6.2.3-25426 Update 2

After updating my longtime GOOD WORKING previous Mosquitto version (1.4.14-9 ??) to the latest 1.6.12-10 it refused to start and gave an error: "Failed to run the package service"
De-install and re-install with default .conf settings was running fine with this newest version.
However ... when I add an extra listener on port 9001 websockets this latest version refused to start giving the same above message.

=================================================================

Extra listeners

=================================================================

AFTER UPGRADE on 5-10-2020 "Extra listeners" next 2 lines were giving ERROR: "Failed to run the package service" !!! ???

listener 9001
protocol websockets
#=================================================================

Changing the port number to other values than 9001 did not solve the problem.

[BenjV]

The port is not the problem, the protocol is the problem
Seems to me that the package is not compiled with websockets and so only support mqtt as protocol

[beardsick]

Thanks BenjV ... this seems a logical explanation ... but why would SynoCommunity do this for their new version if the previous did have websockets working well ?
How can this be solved ?

[BenjV]

Don't no.
Maybe building needs extra or other options and is just the old build process used.

[m7b]

Hi together,
I have the same problem after upgrading from version 1.4.14-9 to 1.6.12.10 on my DS215j.

The mosquitto.log says:
Error: Websockets support not available.

[BenjV]

It seems to be a Mosquitto problem and not a SynoCommunity issue.
see:
eclipse/mosquitto#1740

They say it is fixed, so a new build for this package to upgrade to version 1.6.12 should fix this.

[beardsick]

Hi all, is there any possibility to download the previous stable version 1.4.14-9 (?) as a .spk file for manual install on the Synology ?
I looked for it but can only find the .spk file for the latest version with the bug inside.

[BenjV]

https://synocommunity.com/package/mosquitto

Download the version you want and do a manual install

[arnebjarne]

It seems to be a Mosquitto problem and not a SynoCommunity issue.
see:
eclipse/mosquitto#1740

They say it is fixed, so a new build for this package to upgrade to version 1.6.12 should fix this.

as I read it, it was fixed in 1.6.11...
So this version 1.6.12 must have been compiled without websockets support.

I will try and see if I can compile it myself and see if websockets gets compiled in by default or not.

[BenjV]

Maybe you should read the whole thread before posting already posted information.

[arnebjarne]

Maybe you should read the whole thread before posting already posted information.

lol my bad. Anyway trying to rebuild the package myself right now to see if I can fix the problem.

[hgy59]

Anyway trying to rebuild the package myself right now to see if I can fix the problem.

@arnebjarne can you confirm this is fixed with my latest commit?

[arnebjarne]

Anyway trying to rebuild the package myself right now to see if I can fix the problem.

@arnebjarne can you confirm this is fixed with my latest commit?

Hi hgy59.

I think i still miss some of you patches
libwebsockets 3.2.2 fails compiling due to the openssl issue
Compiling with SSL support
CMake Error at /usr/share/cmake-3.13/Modules/FindPackageHandleStandardArgs.cmake:137 (message):
Could NOT find OpenSSL, try to set the path to OpenSSL root folder in the
system variable OPENSSL_ROOT_DIR (missing: OPENSSL_CRYPTO_LIBRARY) (found
version "1.1.1d")

I will double check your big commit from mosquotto 1.4 to 1.6.12
(nb: I am compiling for DS418 with "make arch-rtd1296)

I get back.

[arnebjarne]

Anyway trying to rebuild the package myself right now to see if I can fix the problem.

@arnebjarne can you confirm this is fixed with my latest commit?

Hi hgy59.

I can confirm that your latest commit ( https://github.com/ymartin59/spksrc/tree/4044_update_mosquitto ) make mosquitto 1.6.12-10 compile with websockets on arch-rtd1296.
( I was missing your openssl fix - cbda607).

I have the version running on my DS418.

[beardsick]

@BenjV , thanks for the link to the downloads of old versions.
I tried them but they seem for Synology DSM 6.1 and I have DSM 6.2.3-25426 Update 2 ... I got an error.
Am I doing something wrong ?

[BenjV]

There is no difference for DSM 6.1 and DSM 6.2 packages, they are all compatible.

But the package is already upgraded to 1.6.12-10 so manual download is not needed anymore.

[ymartin59]

Update 1.6.12-11 published and tested with protocol websockets