Level 1 - Summary on Dioxins

1. What are dioxins?
2. How are humans exposed to dioxins?
3. What are the effects of dioxins in laboratory animals?
4. What are the effects of dioxins on human health?
5. How can dioxin exposure be linked to health effects?
6. Evaluation and conclusions
7. Other views

1. What are dioxins?

1.1. "Dioxins" refers to a group of chlorinated organic chemicals with similar chemical structures. Some have harmful properties, depending on the number and position of chlorine atoms in their chemical structure. One of the most harmful dioxins is known as TCDD. Some PCBs, which have similar properties, are considered "dioxin-like". More...

1.2. Unlike PCBs which were used in several industrial applications, dioxins have no uses. They are formed unintentionally and predominantly released as byproducts of human activities such as incineration and fuel combustion. They are also formed in minor quantities by natural processes such as forest fires and volcanoes. More...

1.3. Dioxins travel through the air and deposit on water or land. In water, dioxins initially bind to small particles or plankton. On land, dioxins deposit on plants or bind to the soil, most often without contaminating groundwater. Animals accumulate dioxins in fat through their food; concentrations increase at each step in the food chain. More...

2. How are humans exposed to dioxins?

2.1 Over 90% of the human intake of dioxins is through food, mainly from animal origin. The intake is ten to hundred times higher for breast fed babies than for adults with respect to their body weight. In most industrialized countries, dioxin exposure has been reduced by almost 50% compared to the early 90's. More...

2.2 Local populations have been accidentally exposed to high dioxin levels, e.g. in Seveso (Italy) after an explosion at a chemical factory, or in Japan and Taiwan with people eating rice oil accidentally contaminated with PCBs and dioxins. In the past, some workers have also been highly exposed to dioxins in waste incineration or chemical plants. More...

2.3 Dioxins are slowly bio-transformed in the body and are not easily eliminated. They tend to accumulate in fat and in the liver. By interacting with a cellular receptor, dioxins can trigger biological effects such as hormonal disturbances and alterations in cell functions. The mechanism of dioxin toxicity is similar in man and other vertebrates. More...

3. What are the effects of dioxins in laboratory animals?

3.1 Toxic dioxins may cause non-cancer effects to animals, affecting development, reproduction, the immune system and the uterus. Human background exposures in industrialized countries have sometimes reached levels at which these effects were seen in animals. More...

3.2 In laboratory testing, TCDD and some other types of dioxins increase the number of cancers in several animal species, in both sexes. They do not initiate cancers but promote the growth of existing precancerous cell. More...

4. What are the effects of dioxins on human health?

4.1 For workers accidentally exposed to the highest doses of dioxins, studies estimate that the risk of cancer increases by about 40%. However, the average exposure of the general population is much lower. More...

4.2 Some delay in nervous system development as well as changes of behavior were seen in children of mothers who had been highly exposed to dioxins and PCBs. In some cases these effects occurred even at current background levels. The effects were likely due to exposure through the placenta rather than through breast milk. However, at least in one case high levels of PCBs and dioxins in breast milk were shown to affect young children's neurobehavioural test results. More...

4.3 Other non-cancer effects observed on adults accidentally exposed to high levels of toxic dioxins include: diabetes, liver and heart diseases, skin problems (e.g. chloracne), conjunctivitis, fatigue, malaise and slowed nervous reactions. More...

6. Evaluation and conclusions

6.1 Dioxin levels in food, environmental samples and breast milk have decreased over the 1990s. In most industrialized countries, the daily dioxin intake is currently in the order of 1 to 3 pg I-TEQ/kg body weight per day. More...

6.2 At very high dioxin exposure, the risk for all cancers combined appears to increase. Non-cancer effects include cardiovascular diseases, diabetes and changes in blood composition. Infants of accidentally highly exposed mothers showed severe developmental and neurological effects. More...

6.3 A Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) of 1 to 4 pg I-TEQ per kg body weight per day has been established for dioxins by the World Health Organization (WHO). The upper limit of 4 is provisional: the ultimate goal is to reduce human intake levels below 1 pg I-TEQ per kg body weight per day. This value was derived from the lowest doses causing adverse effects in experimental animals, divided by a safety factor of 10. This Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI) should be seen as an average over a life-time, implying that this value may be exceeded occasionally for short periods without expected health consequences. More...

6.4 Although breast-fed infants are more exposed to dioxins, under normal conditions the many beneficial effects of human milk generally outweigh the risks. Dioxin levels in human milk have been reduced since the early 90's. More...

7. Other views

This summary is based on the latest WHO-IPCS "Assessment of the health risk of dioxins: re-evaluation of the Tolerable Daily Intake (TDI)". It is considered by most scientists as a consensus document and other recent scientific assessments reach similar conclusions - click here for some links

However, some people and organizations put forward different views:

• Positions suggesting that Dioxins pose more risk
  
  
• Positions suggesting that Dioxins pose less risk