Oxygen Not Included

Oxygen Not Included

48 ratings
Heat Transfer and Materials Science
By El Biznatchio
Guide on thermal properties of materials and effects on heat transfer
4
   
Award
Favorite
Favorited
Unfavorite
Intro
Efficiency has always been a question of mine, and while I have frequently managed to make it to the end game, I've never really reached the point where I was attempting to max out efficiencies. This guide is my attempt to review how materials interact and how best to use them for managing heat.

My tests were short but I was able to gather the information I needed to determine efficiencies.

The materials are listed in this guide with a brief explanation of systems.

These will remain on the top of the guide for ease of use.
Insulated Tiles and Pipes
Insulated Tiles and Insulated Pipes function in the same manner, to create a barrier for the movement of thermal energy or heat. The most important attribute is the Thermal Conductivity, this will determine how rapidly heat transfers to the tile. This is followed by Specific Heat Capacity, or how much thermal energy is need to heat the material.

With Thermal Conductivity, the number closer to 0 is more desirable. While with Specific Heat Capacity, the higher the value the better. As all materials have low Thermal Conductivity, small differences can impact heat transfer greatly.

Materials are listed in ranking from best to worst.

Be mindful of Melting Point

Insulated Tiles

Mass (Kg): 400

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
**Insulation
5.57
0
3621.9
*Isoresin
1.3
0.002
100
Ceramic
0.84
0.006
1849.9
Mafic Rock
0.2
0.01
1409.9
Igneous Rock
1
0.02
1409.9
Fossil
0.91
0.02
1338.9
Sedimentary Rock
0.2
0.02
926.9
Obsidian
0.2
0.02
2726.9
Sandstone
0.8
0.029
926.9
Granite
0.79
0.034
668.9

*Isoresin: even with the extremely low Thermal Conductivity, I would avoid using this material as at some point I would expect it to melt

**Insulation: I would not use this for tiles unless you are starved for space, anything this could be used for can likely be surrounded by a 1 tile wide vacuum. Vacuum costs are simply space and whatever tile material chosen to surround.



Insulated Liquid Pipes

Mass (Kg): 400

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Insulation
5.57
0
3621.9
Ceramic
0.84
0.019
1849.9
Igneous Rock
1
0.063
1409.9
Sedimentary Rock
0.2
0.063
926.9
Obsidian
0.2
0.063
2726.9
Sandstone
0.8
0.91
926.9
Granite
0.79
0.106
668.9
Wolframite
0.134
0.469
2926.9
Tungsten
0.134
1.875
3421.9
Thermium
0.622
6.875
2676.9

Liquid Bridges

Mass (Kg): 100

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Insulation
5.57
0
3621.9
Isoresin
1.3
0.17
100
Ceramic
0.84
0.62
1849.9
Mafic Rock
0.2
1
1409.9
Igneous Rock
1
2
1409.9
Fossil
0.91
2
1338.9
Sedimentary Rock
0.2
2
926.9
Obsidian
0.2
2
2726.9
Sandstone
0.8
2.9
926.9
Granite
0.79
3.39
668.9

Insulated Gas Pipes

Mass (Kg): 400

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Insulation
5.570
0
3621.9
Isoresin
1.3
0.005
100
Ceramic
0.84
0.019
1849.9
Mafic Rock
0.2
0.031
1409.9
Igneous Rock
1
0.063
1409.9
Fossil
0.91
0.063
1338.9
Sedimentary Rock
0.2
0.063
926.9
Obsidian
0.2
0.063
2726.9
Sandstone
0.8
0.091
926.9
Granite
0.79
0.106
668.9

Gas Bridges

Mass (Kg): 50

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Insulation
5.57
0
3621.9
Isoresin
1.3
0.17
100
Ceramic
0.84
0.62
1849.9
Mafic Rock
0.2
1
1409.9
Igneous Rock
1
2
1409.9
Fossil
0.91
2
1338.9
Sedimentary Rock
0.2
2
926.9
Obsidian
0.2
2
2769.9
Sandstone
0.8
2.9
926.9
Granite
0.79
3.39
668.9
Metal Tiles, Radiant Pipes and Tempshift Plates
The purpose of these objects is to shift thermal energy, so with these objects we want a high Specific Heat Capacity and a high Thermal Conductivity.

Initially, Specific Heat Capacity to stabilize temperatures will be of importance, but that will quickly be overtaken by Thermal Conductivity.

Cases where the Thermal Conductivity values are nearly identical, Specific Heat Capacity should be reviewed.

***Thoughts, based on mix-match of Thermal Conductivity and Specific Heat Capacity on materials, if you do not have access to the top tier materials: Steal or Iron and Copper for cooling or taking heat from one place; Gold or Tungsten for heating a place. If you're gathering heat use the first materials, if you're releasing heat (say into a boiler/steam generator) the second set.
Metal Tiles

Mass: 100 Kg

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point
Thermium
0.622
220
2676.9
Aluminum
0.91
205
660.3
Copper
0.385
60
1083.9
*Tungsten
0.134
60
3421.9
Gold
0.129
60
1063.9
Steel
0.49
54
2426.9
Iron
0.449
55
1534.9
Niobium
0.265
54
2476.9
Lead
0.128
35
327.5

Radiant Liquid Pipes

Mass (Kg): 50

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Thermium
0.622
440
2676.9
Aluminum
0.91
410
660.3
Copper
0.385
120
1083.9
*Tungsten
0.134
120
3412.9
Gold
0.129
120
1063.9
Steel
0.49
108
2426.9
Iron
0.449
110
1543.9
Niobium
0.265
108
2476.9
Lead
0.128
70
327.5

Radiant Gas Pipes

Mass (Kg): 25

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Thermium
0.622
440
2676.9
Niobium
0.265
108
2476.9
Steel
0.49
108
2426.9
Aluminum Ore
0.91
41
1083.9
*Wolframite
0.134
30
2926.9
Mercury
0.14
16.6
-38.8
Copper Ore
0.386
9
1083.9
Pyrite
0.386
9
1083.9
Iron Ore
0.449
8
1534.9
Electrum
0.15
4
1063.9
Gold Amalgam
0.15
4
1063.9

Tempshift Plates

Many of these are here for informational purposes and will not be sorted.

Mass (Kg): 800

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Thermium
0.622
220
2676.9
Aluminum
0.91
205
660.3
Diamond
0.516
80
3926.9
Copper
0.385
60
1083.9
*Tungsten
0.134
60
3421.9
Gold
0.129
60
1063
Steel
0.49
54
2426.9
Iron
0.449
55
1534.9
Niobium
0.265
54
2476.9
Lead
0.128
35
327.5
Aluminum Ore
0.91
20.5
1083.9
*Wolframite
0.134
15
2926.9

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
Melting Point (ºC):
Copper Ore
0.386
4.5
1083.9
Sand Cement
1.5
8
1409.9
Mercury
0.14
8.3
-38.8
Brick
0.84
0.62
1409.9
Electrum
0.15
2
1063.9
Carbon Fiber
0.52
0
4726.9
Propane
2.4
1
-188.2
Sandstone
0.8
2.9
926.9
Coal
0.71
1
276.9
Building Slab
0.52
8
1409.9
Dirt
1.48
2
326.9
Cement
1.55
8
1409.9
Cement Mix
0.52
8
1409.9
Pyrite
0.386
4.5
1083.9
Igneous Rock
1
2
1409.9
Granite
0.79
3.39
668.9
Sedimentary Rock
0.2
2
926.9
Iron Ore
0.449
4
1534.9
Obsidian
0.2
2
2726.9
Gold Amalgam
0.15
2
1063.9
Clay
0.92
2
926.9
Brine Ice
3.4
2.18
-16.5
Ceramic
0.84
0.62
1849.9
Glass
0.84
1.11
1426.9
Ice
2.05
2.18
-0.6
Polluted Ice
3.05
1
-20.6
Plastic
1.92
0.15
159.9
Mafic Rock
0.2
1
1409.9
Insulation
5.57
0
3621.9

*Tungsten and Wolframite should be saved for high temperature or extreme low temperature settings.
Liquids & Gases
Liquids and gases are primarily used for transporting heat, that is gathering heat from one location and moving it to another. If you use cooling systems, you are only taking heat from the location you want to cool and moving it.

For this reason you want high Specific Heat Capacity and high Thermal Conductivity. For ease of use we will be sorting the materials by *Coefficient. This value is the product of those two attributes.

As usual Thermal Conductivity should be the most important value.

Liquids

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
*Coefficient:
Freeze Point (ºC):
Vaporization Point (ºC):
Super Coolant
8.44
9.46
79.8424
-271.2
436.9
Steel
0.386
80
30.88
1083.9
3826.9
Molten Aluminum
0.91
20.5
18.655
660.3
2470
Niobium
0.265
54
14.31
2476.9
4743.9
Copper
0.386
12
4.632
1083.9
2560.9
Petroleum
1.76
2
3.52
-57.1
538.9
Crude Oil
1.69
2
3.38
-40.1
399.9
Water
4.179
0.609
2.545011
-0.6
99.4
Salt Water
4.1
0.609
2.4969
-7.5
99.7
Polluted Water
4.179
0.58
2.42382
-20.6
119.4
Brine
3.4
0.609
2.0706
-22.5
102.8
Oxygen
1.01
2
2.02
-218.8
-183
Iron
0.449
4
1.796
1534.9
2749.9
Carbon
0.71
2
1.42
3551.9
4826.9
Molten Lead
0.128
11
1.408
327.5
1749
Carbon Dioxide
0.846
1.46
1.23516
-56.5
-48.1
Magma
1
1
1
1409.9
2356.9
Gold
0.129
6
0.774
1063.9
2855.9
Visco-Gel
1.55
0.45
0.6975
-30.6
479.9
Tungsten
0.134
4
0.536
3421.9
5929.9
Naphtha
2.191
0.2
0.4382
-50.1
538.9
Ethanol
2.46
0.171
0.42066
-114.1
78.4
Molten Salt
0.7
0.444
0.3108
799.9
1464.9
Propane
2.4
0.1
0.24
-188.2
-42.1
Hydrogen
2.4
0.1
0.24
-259.2
-252.2
Molten Glass
0.2
1
0.2
1126.9
2356.9
Phosphorus
0.77
0.235
0.18095
44.1
280.5
Liquid Sulfur
0.7
0.2
0.14
115.2
337
Methane
2.191
0.03
0.06573
-182.6
-161.5
*Chlorine
0.48
0.008
0.00384
-101
-34.6

Gases

Specific Heat Capacity:
Thermal Conductivity:
*Coefficient:
Condensation Point (ºC):
Super Coolant
8.44
1.2
10.128
436.9
Aluminum
0.91
2.5
2.275
2470
Carbon
0.71
1.7
1.207
4826.9
Steam
4.179
0.184
0.768936
99.4
Steel
0.49
1
0.49
3826.9
Iron
0.449
1
0.449
2749.9
Lead
0.128
3.5
0.448
1749
Hydrogen
2.4
0.168
0.4032
-252.2
Salt Gas
0.88
0.444
0.39072
1469.9
Copper
0.386
1
0.386
2560.9
Ethanol
2.148
0.167
0.358716
78.4
Niobium
0.265
1
0.265
4743.9
Phosphorus
0.77
0.236
0.18172
280.5
Sulfur
0.7
0.2
0.14
337
Tungsten
0.134
1
0.134
5929.9
Gold
0.129
1
0.129
2855.9
Rock Gas
1
0.1
0.1
2356.9
Natural Gas
2.191
0.035
0.076685
-161.5
Propane
2.4
0.015
0.036
-42.1
Sour Gas
1.898
0.018
0.034164
-161.5
Polluted Oxygen
1.01
0.024
0.02424
-183
Oxygen
1.005
0.024
0.02412
-183
Carbon Dioxide
0.846
0.015
0.01269
-48.1
*Chlorine
0.48
0.008
0.00384
-34.6

*Chlorine can be used an insulator due to its abundance, however I will always recommend a vacuum gap over any other materials as nothing is a better insulator than hard vacuum.
Closing
Tests were simple:

I used 5x4 blocks of insulated tiles and metal tiles with 2 "windows" 1x2 holes filled with hydrogen.



I used the measurements to determine how much the hydrogen in the left window decreased, and how much the hydrogen increased on the right. With this I was able to determine the properties of the materials and expectations on use.

For all materials the most important factor appears to be Thermal Conductivity, this determines how quickly materials heat, and transfers any heat. After that is the Specific Heat Capacity or how much thermal energy it takes to heat the object.

The metal tile tests were somewhat surprising. The objects with higher Specific Heat Capacity pulled heat more effectively from the left, but were poor at moving the heat to the right, while objects with higher Thermal Conductivity were more effective at heating the windows on the right but with higher temperatures also on the left. Thus if the goal is to remove heat, we probably want objects with higher Specific Heat Capacity, but we also want higher Thermal Conductivity so it can more efficiently transfer the heat. I am really torn on this one, but I will default to Thermal Conductivity being more important than Specific Heat Capacity.

*Further thoughts on the matter are that for situations where temperature will be more steady to default to higher Thermal Conductivity, in situations where temperatures can spike (such as geysers and volcanos) we want a higher Specific Heat Capacity to more effectively manage the heat. This again is going to depend on what we are using to manage the heat. If we are using an Aquatuner then Higher Specific Heat Capacity to reduce energy costs. If a Steam Turbine, higher Thermal Conductivity.

For insulating materials we want a high Specific Heat Capacity with a low Thermal Conductivity, this will allow the object to slowly heat and slowly transfer its heat.

For conducting materials we want a low Specific Heat Capacity with a high Thermal Conductivity, this allows the object to heat quickly and require less energy to heat. This also allows it to more effectively transfer its heat.

For Coolants (Liquids and Gases) We want high Specific Heat Capacity and Thermal Conductivity.
This allows the object to heat slowly and also quickly transfer any heat it obtains.

Important formulas:

Specific Heat Capacity: #value(DTU/g)/ ºC is required to heat 1 g of the selected object by 1 ºC

Thermal Conductivity: This object can conduct heat to other materials at a rate of Thermal
Conductivity #value(DTU/(m*s))/ ºC W for each degree ºC difference
Between two objects, the rate of heat transfer will be determined by the object with the lowest Thermal Conductivity



Thanks!
7 Comments
< blank > 27 Oct, 2020 @ 11:20pm 
The best source for this kinda information is the wiki: https://oxygennotincluded.gamepedia.com/Thermal_Conductivity

A few issues with your conclusions/tables: When using a liquid or gas in a radient pipe (you're trying to move heat), the thermal conductivity of the material doesn't matter, only the radiant pipe. This means you only care about specific heat. This is also true if you're using an aquatuner, as it drops the liquid a constant -14d, which removes more heat for a high specific heat. Knowing this, the second best liquid to use in a cooling loop is (polluted) water (first being super coolant). Also, the best gas to use is hydrogen.
Apophis 21 Oct, 2020 @ 6:53pm 
Perfect, saved me so much time, I gave you a golden unicorn!
El Biznatchio  [author] 5 Sep, 2020 @ 9:18am 
It is! I'll have to fix that.
lashtear 5 Sep, 2020 @ 12:56am 
Ethanol condensation point seems to be a typocopy of the coefficient, but neat breakdown!
taganno 24 Aug, 2020 @ 4:37am 
Pppp
El Biznatchio  [author] 18 Jul, 2020 @ 6:19pm 
:COCrune3:
[9gL]Vasion 18 Jul, 2020 @ 3:42pm 
Nerd.