-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 2.6k
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
During playback, L/R arrow keys should move playback cursor instead of selection #16519
Comments
I agree that the user's original selection should not dictate where the playhead moves to when the user presses the right / left keys as the score is being played. Pressing right / left should just move the cursor forward or back from it's current position. It should not move the selection, which in turn moves the selection in a weird way. I'm not going to comment on the smooth cursor here. That's a separate issue, which some may have differing feelings on. Let's not discuss that here and stick to one issue per ticket. |
I'm un-assigning myself, since I think the way forward is clear. When a score is being played, pressing left or right should move the playhead's current position. It should not move the original note that was selected before play was pressed. |
The playback cursor as it stands creates specific workflow issues. Previously in MuseScore 3 and prior, if you pressed the left/right arrow keys while in playback mode, the playback cursor would either go forwards or backwards and was dependent on the playback cursor position. This was good because there are many times where you want to listen to a whole section, and then skip to the next section by just holding right. Now, instead the playback cursor's position is dependent on what was last selected, meaning if you've selected a measure to start playback and have listened to, for example, 40 measures of music, and then want to skip the next 8 measures to listen to the next section, then that means you have to hold right for 48 measures, as opposed to just 8, or alternatively stop playback and scroll to the next section. Both options are slower than the previous functionality of the playback cursor. A viable solution would be to add preferences for the playback cursor to allow toggling between the previous functionality, or the current functionality.
Also, personal preference, I strongly dislike the smooth motion of the current playback cursor. There are many times where I want to actually see the beats getting "played" by the playback cursor. Again, a preference to toggle between old functionality versus current functionality is the most viable option to please all parties.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: