Example from README is not working

[rannn505]

Im using create react app v5.0.1 with react v17.0.2 and getting

[albingroen]

Hi, do you mind posting a reproducible repository or a code sandbox?

[rannn505]

@albingroen not sure whats the difference (except sandbox is JS and local is TS) here but I couldn't reproduce it over there
https://codesandbox.io/s/angry-gauss-rcz3j8?file=/src/App.js

Im not sure why I getting this error but maybe a bit of a research on what is the root cause of such an error can help us here

[albingroen]

@albingroen not sure whats the difference (except sandbox is JS and local is TS) here but I couldn't reproduce it over there https://codesandbox.io/s/angry-gauss-rcz3j8?file=/src/App.js

Im not sure why I getting this error but maybe a bit of a research on what is the root cause of such an error can help us here

I think it might be a React 18 issue. The sandbox seems to be using v17. Which version are you using?

[honzasusek]

@albingroen Getting the exact same error here on React 17.0.2. Will try to reproduce in sandbox.

[albingroen]

@albingroen Getting the exact same error here on React 17.0.2. Will try to reproduce in sandbox.

Are you using create-react-app?

[honzasusek]

@honzasusek Yeah, version 5.0.0 + typescript 4.6.2.

[rannn505]

Im using create react app v5.0.1 with react v17.0.2 and getting

@albingroen just mentioned it in the initial comment.

I assume that the issue comes from parts in the code that are not backward compatible with react 17 ...
let us know if we can help ... and thanks 🙏🏽

[albingroen]

For some weird reason, it works in codesandbox but not locally. Just tried downloading the zip and running it, but I'm running in to the same issue...

[rannn505]

@albingroen any progress here? do you need help?

[albingroen]

@albingroen any progress here? do you need help?

Not really any progress. Would love some help!

[honzasusek]

@albingroen Not sure if this will help, but I just copied the package contents over to our repo, fixed the imports and it seems to be running just fine like that. Could this be a build-related issue? That might explain why codesandbox is working fine with the same setup.

[albingroen]

@albingroen Not sure if this will help, but I just copied the package contents over to our repo, fixed the imports and it seems to be running just fine like that. Could this be a build-related issue? That might explain why codesandbox is working fine with the same setup.

Hmm, that sounds really weird...

[albingroen]

@honzasusek Do you mind putting up that repo or inviting me to it so I can see it?

[honzasusek]

@albingroen I'm afraid that isn't possible, but I think I could at least share our tsconfig.json, package.json + a general outline of our setup over PM.

[albingroen]

@honzasusek Alright, you can DM me here

[honzasusek]

@albingroen no twitter account, sorry, sent you an email instead 👴

[dutziworks]

I was able to reproduce on a simple CRA project:

npx create-react-app my-project --template typescript
yarn add react-cmdk
yarn start

Then add the code from the readme into the app.

[dutziworks]

Also, I'm adding these tags so people will find this issue easily:

Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'Child')

[carbonrider]

Having same issue with React 18 on local machine. It is not working and throwing

Uncaught TypeError: Cannot read properties of undefined (reading 'Child')

[carbonrider]

It seems there is an ongoing discussion about React 18 and Transition component compatibility. I see react-cmdk using Transition component. Check the details here.

tailwindlabs/headlessui#681

[albingroen]

I don't have the capacity to solve this, unfortunately, so I will close this for now :/

[tanmayairbase]

facing the same issue as well, also was working on codesandbox