Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Mark the model for Sweden as invalid or similar #71

Open
DrChr opened this issue Apr 16, 2020 · 2 comments
Open

Mark the model for Sweden as invalid or similar #71

DrChr opened this issue Apr 16, 2020 · 2 comments

Comments

@DrChr
Copy link

DrChr commented Apr 16, 2020

Due to the model for Sweden using incorrect data, I think you should somehow mark the corresponding web page [1] as invalid or something. Perhaps you could add a banner or note at the top of the web page. Or maybe just remove it.

As for why the data I say the data it's using is invalid, have a look at the the screenshots below for comparison. See #58 for additional details.

I also wonder if you have checked the data for other countries?

N:o deceased for different days as taken from Sweden's "Folkhälsomyndighet" on the 16th of April:
image

Compare this with what's currently (on the 16th) being shown on the model for Sweden:
image

[1] https://mrc-ide.github.io/covid19estimates/#/details/Sweden

@DrChr
Copy link
Author

DrChr commented Apr 16, 2020

Below is a comparison of data from Folkhälsomyndigheten (FOHM) and data I just downloaded from ECDC's web site:

Date FOHM ECDC Error
3/11/2020 1 0 1
3/12/2020 0 1 -1
3/13/2020 1 0 1
3/14/2020 1 0 1
3/15/2020 2 0 2
3/16/2020 2 2 0
3/17/2020 1 4 -3
3/18/2020 6 1 5
3/19/2020 7 2 5
3/20/2020 10 0 10
3/21/2020 7 6 1
3/22/2020 12 4 8
3/23/2020 11 1 10
3/24/2020 20 4 16
3/25/2020 25 11 14
3/26/2020 30 6 24
3/27/2020 32 24 8
3/28/2020 35 26 9
3/29/2020 38 10 28
3/30/2020 42 8 34
3/31/2020 43 36 7
4/1/2020 50 34 16
4/2/2020 68 59 9
4/3/2020 71 43 28
4/4/2020 61 51 10
4/5/2020 79 40 39
4/6/2020 85 28 57
4/7/2020 75 76 -1
4/8/2020 97 114 -17
4/9/2020 63 96 -33
4/10/2020 62 106 -44
4/11/2020 61 77 -16
4/12/2020 62 17 45
4/13/2020 55 12 43
4/14/2020 49 20 29
4/15/2020 41 114 -73
4/16/2020 10 170 -152
Date missing: 18    

@offroff
Copy link

offroff commented Apr 26, 2020

The data from the swedish authorities are quite problematic, I wouldn't use it. Also, the swedish data has fooled the authority itself and the swedish people. The ECDC data is probably a lot more useful.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

2 participants